There’s little more disappointing than when a beloved TV show is canceled before its time. Manygreat TV shows were canceled in 2024, andin recent years, more series have been axed before they have had the chance to prove their qualitythan ever before. There’s a lot of pressure, particularly from streaming services, on modern TV series to be explosively popular from the start and justify their budget and resources, even when the streamer doesn’t shell out for a significant marketing campaign.
It’s always upsetting when you’re worried aTV show won’t finish its story without being canceled, and when this does happen, it leaves the narrative on a cliffhanger forever. While dedicated fans have no trouble envisioning theories and possible endings for series that never reach their planned conclusions, this isn’t as satisfying as the real thing. Though no series should be canceled before its time, it’s even more frustrating when the shows are popular with a wide array of audiences and still have a lot more story to tell.
The Recruitwas widely considered Netflix’s answer to the immensely popularReacherand a way to capitalize on the momentum of the record-breakingThe Night Agent. Unfortunately, sinceThe Recruitfailed to compare to both titles, it was recently axed by Netflix, ending after season 2. Led by Noah Centineo,The Recruitsurprised audiences with how fun and dynamic the action-thriller was,rising above the moniker of “dad TV” and becoming an interesting study of the spy genre.
However, Netflix is quick to cancel its original series if they’re not performingas well as the streamer might hope, andThe Recruitfell victim to this practice. Though there are elements ofThe Recruitthat are on the predictable side, this was part of the fun of the project. If it had been renewed for season 3, there’s no reason whyThe Recruitcouldn’t have kept getting better and competing with the biggest action titles on TV. Centineo was improving with each season and proving himself to be more than his rom-com roots might suggest.
77%
82%
While the originalHigh Fidelitymovie from 2000 is an iconic addition to the music and rom-com genres, the 2020 TV show revival brought the story into the modern era.Starring Zoë Kravitz as Rob, the protagonist,theHigh FidelityTV show benefited from telling the story through the lens of a complex female character. Imperfect and, at times, self-involved, Rob was still a great character to spend time with, taking the audience on a romantic odyssey across New York City.
ThoughHigh Fidelityhad exhausted the premise of the movie after season 1, the series had an exciting opportunity to explore the supporting characters further and delve into the vivid world the writers had crafted.Still steeped in a love of music and physical media,High Fidelityappealed to viewers of all kindsand never failed to remain exciting as it chronicled Rob’s failed attempts to find love. With the endlessly charming Kravitz leading the cast,High Fidelitycould’ve run for many seasons.
86%
79%
I Am Not Okay With Thisis aNetflix original TV show that didn’t deserve to be canceled, as the streaming service has become notorious for canceling exciting new series before their time.Based on the graphic novel by Charles Forsman,I Am Not Okay With Thisblends dark elements of the fantasy genrewith the emotional highs and lows of adolescence. Starring Sophia Lillis as the protagonist, Sydney,I Am Not Okay With Thisended season 1 with a thrilling cliffhanger that would’ve taken Sydney to new heights as a character.
Great additions to the supernatural teen TV show genre have been few and far between in recent years, especially when they’re as emotionally compelling and truthful asI Am Not Okay With This.
Unfortunately, this was not to be, andI Am Not Okay With Thisseason 1 will have to be enough for fans to revisit time and again as the years progress. Great additions to the supernatural teen TV show genre have been few and far between in recent years, especially when they’re as emotionally compelling and truthful asI Am Not Okay With This. Hopefully, the comic series might find new life again one day, as it’s an enduring story.
Westworlddidn’t have an easy time while it was on the air, as it was a popular show to theorize about due to its shocking twists and turns. However, this level of shock factor and plot twists can sometimes be difficult for a series to maintain, andWestworldmade some missteps after its iconic first outing. Despite this,Westworldwas returning to form by the end of season 4,and it’s inarguable that fans of the series deserved to get a satisfying conclusion.
The writers and showrunners were prepared forWestworldseason 5, setting up many storylines to be carried over into this installment, but this wasn’t to be. Even though there are hopes that HBO might revive the sci-fi Western, it’s been over three years since the last season, and season 5 is no closer to being brought to life onscreen. This abrupt and tragic ending will always color the legacy ofWestworld, which once seemed like the most promising new show of the 2010s.
80%
75%
Crafting a teen-driven TV show that is entertaining and fun while also feeling realistic and truthful is a tall order. This makes it all the more impactful when a series like this does come along and even more devastating when it’s canceled too soon. Netflix’sEverything Sucks!joins the ranks of brilliant teen shows likeFreaks and GeeksandMy So-Called Lifethat were canceled after season 1 but have maintained their iconography and legacy thanks to their undeniable quality of content.
It’s true thatEverything Sucks!leans into the inherent nostalgia of its premise, as it’s set in the 1990s.
Featuring performances from a young Sydney Sweeney as well as Jahi Di’Allo Winston and Peyton Kennedy,Everything Sucks!treads familiar ground about feeling insecure and out of place in high school. However, it does so with a fresh twist, including fantastic LGBTQ+ representation. It’s true thatEverything Sucks!leans into the inherent nostalgia of its premise, as it’s set in the 1990s. Despite this, it deserved to run for additional seasons and keep finding itself.
72%
91%
My Lady Janeis arecent TV show that deserved a lot more attention, as this might have saved the series from being canceled after season 1.The historical fantasy show made waves as soon as it premiered on Prime Video,appealing to fans of fantasy, romance, and historical retellings, as well as any audience member who enjoys some hilarious action and adventure. Despite the outcry from fans and praise from iconic fantasy writers like George R.R. Martin, the show hasn’t been brought back.
Canceling any series after just one season always seems like a waste, as the story barely had a chance to get off the ground and show its full potential. Emily Bader and Edward Bluemel starred as the primary protagonists, Jane and Guildford, and while their chemistry is a large part of what made the series shine, the entire ensemble came together to create a show as funny as it was moving. As the years progress, it’s likely thatMy Lady Janewill be considered a cult classic that was well ahead of its time.
95%
Brit Marling is brilliant inThe OAas the titular character in one of Netflix’s most mind-bending projectsto date. She’s joined by a stellar ensemble cast featuring Jason Isaacs, who has recently risen to prominence once again for his starring role inThe White Lotusseason 3. Though multiple realities and parallel universes have been popular topics in science fiction and fantasy in recent years, few movies or TV shows were able to tackle this concept with the depth, nuance, and metatextual references thatThe OAhandled with ease.
The OAwas tragically canceled after season 2,and the response from fans of the series was overwhelming. Part of this was because the show ended on an unresolved plot point, and it was widely regarded as one of the best TV shows of the 21st century. WhileThe OAseason 1 was intriguing and enticing, season 2 raised the stakes and got even better, demonstrating thatThe OAwas a series that would continue evolving and improving. It’s interesting and devastating to imagine whereThe OAmight have gone if it had stayed on the air.
84%
83%
The scale and budget that went into Netflix’s original thriller series,Mindhunter, contributed to the early cancellation of the phenomenal show. Though there have been plenty of recent projects that touch upon criminal profiling and the hunt for serial killers,Mindhunterwas unlike anything else seen on television. With acclaimed directorDavid Fincher serving as one of the executive producers and one of the primary directors,Mindhunterwas a near-perfect series.
Though fans and critics have been clamoring for a revival of the series since it went off the air, it’s unlikely that we’ll ever see Holden, Bill, and Wendy return to our screens. This is a shame, asMindhunterseason 2 concluded with a cliffhanger, demonstrating that one of the killers is still at large.While this open-ended finale reflects the true frustration of working to track down notorious killers, it’s clear thatMindhunterhad a lot more story to tell and that the terrific ensemble was up to the task of telling it.
97%
