The 2022 Western movieMurder at Yellowstone Cityutilizes its well-known cast in creating a dramatic murder mystery.Murder at Yellowstone Cityis an interesting cross between a classic Western setting and characters and amurder mystery plot. The movie begins with a classic set-up: Robert Dunnigan strikes gold just as his boomtown needs it most, but the next morning, he is found dead. With the local sheriff already going down the wrong path, it is up to the town’s pastor and his wife to bring the true killer to justice.
There is certainly no shortage of drama and deceit inMurder at Yellowstone City,which is aided by the performances of its leads. ThoughMurder at Yellowstone Cityreceived poor reviewsfor its use of Western stereotypes and predictable dialogue, the movie is nonetheless entertaining.Murder at Yellowstone Cityis perfect for fans ofslow-burn Westerns, and it allows audiences to get a good look at all the characters before unveiling who the culprit is.
Isaiah Mustafa As Cicero
Date Of Birth: June 06, 2025
Actor:Isaiah Mustafa was born in Portland, Oregon, in 1974, and he began his career as a football player before turning his attention to acting several years later. In the mid to late 2000s, Mustafa began appearing in guest roles in various TV series and movies, includingUgly Betty, NCIS, and more. During this time, he also gained attention for appearing in Old Spice commercials.Mustafa is best known for portraying Mike Hanlon inIt Chapter Two, and he has alsoappeared in the showsShadowhuntersandCross.
Cross
John Sampson
Character:Isaiah Mustafa stars as Cicero in Murder at Yellowstone City. Cicero is the new character in town, and because his arrival coincides with the death of Robert Dunnigan, the town sheriff immediately suspects him. Cicero is calm and smart, reciting Shakespeare and poetry throughout the movie in spite of being targeted by a racist sheriff.
Gabriel Byrne As Sheriff Jim Abrose
Date Of Birth: Jun 26, 2025
Actor:Gabriel Byrne was born in Dublin, Ireland, in 1950 and began acting in theater productions during the 1970s. Byrne rose to fame appearing in TV shows like The Riordans and Bracken before appearing in further shows and movies. Byrne has been in numerous acclaimed productions throughout his career, buthe is best known for films likeThe Usual Suspects, The Man in the Iron Mask, and, more recently,Hereditary.
Hereditary
Steve Graham
Character:Gabriel Byrne stars as the town Sheriff, Jim Abrose, inMurder at Yellowstone City. While Jim believes that he is helping his town’s people find justice for the murder of Robert Dunnigan, his racist views of Cicero mean that he overlooks any real evidence that could help solve the crime, leading to a divide in the town.
Thomas Jane As Thaddeus Murphy
Date Of Birth: Jul 19, 2025
Actor:Thomas Jane was born in Baltimore, Maryland, in 1969, and he began acting as a teenager. At the beginning of his career, Jane appeared in small roles in successful movies such asBoogie Nights, The Thin Red Line, andMagnolia. He then gained attention for starring in Deep Blue Sea andreceived critical acclaim for playing Mickey Mantle in61*. After his rise to fame, Jane gained lead roles inStander, The Punisher, andThe Mist. On TV, he hasstarred inThe Expanse,Hung, andTroppo.
The Predator
Baxley
Character:Thomas Jane stars as Thaddeus Murphy inMurder at Yellowstone City. Thaddeus is the town’s preacher and is married to Alice, though he has a few secrets in his past. The two of them come to believe that Cicero is innocent and work to prove that, despite the Sheriff’s attempts to stop them.
Murder At Yellowstone City Supporting Cast & Characters
Anna Camp as Alice Murphy: Anna Camp plays Alice Murphy, the wife of Thaddeus Murphy and one of the first people to believe Cicero to be innocent. Anna Camp is best known for her appearances in thePitch Perfectmovie series and in the TV showTrue Blood.
Aimee Garcia as Isabel Santos: Aimee Garcia stars as Isabel Santos inMurder at Yellowstone City. Isabel is a sex worker at the local saloon and is a respected businesswoman. Aimee Garcia is known for her appearances onThe George Lopez Show,Dexter, andLucifer.
Nat Wolff As Jimmy Ambrose Jr.: Nat Wolff stars as the Sheriff’s son, Jimmy Ambrose Jr., inMurder at Yellowstone City. Wolff rose to fame at a young age after starring inThe Naked Brothers Bandon Nickelodeon. Wolff has also starred inPaper Towns, Home Again, Death Note, and more.
Richard Dreyfuss as Edgar Blake: Richard Dreyfuss appears inMurder at Yellowstone Cityas the saloon owner Edgar Blake. Dreyfuss has had a long and celebrated career, starring in well-known films such asJaws, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, The Goodbye Girl, Mr. Holland’s Opus, and more.
